...Many Refuse To Take It?
The following is from Sarah Zhang writing in The Atlantic:
...There is no COVID-19 vaccine, but there are already COVID-19 vaccine conspiracies. Even as vaccines for the disease caused by SARS-CoV-2 are being held up as the last hope for a return to normalcy, misinformation about them is spreading. A more fraught scenario for science communication is hard to imagine: a novel vaccine, probably fast-tracked, in the middle of a highly politicized and badly mishandled pandemic.
“I was initially optimistic that, when people felt the need for a COVID-19 vaccine, the anti-vaccination movement would undergo a period of retreat,” says Peter Hotez, a vaccine scientist at Baylor College of Medicine, who has himself become a frequent target of vaccine skeptics. “It’s actually had the effect of reinvigorating the anti-vaccine movement.”...
Now.
Like me until relatively recently, you may have thought that the anti-vaxxers are just a lunatic fringe group whose arguments do not really matter in the grand scheme of the thinking of the rational 'rest of us'.
Clinician-scientist David Gorski, who has bona-fides that I trust in this fight, begs to differ:
...I admire Dr. Hotez to death, but until recently he really was quite naïve about the antivaccine movement, as are many doctors and scientists. I even fell into that category several years ago, thinking that vaccines are the victims of their own success and that, because we don’t see the mass suffering now due to the diseases we now vaccinate against, the return of such an infectious disease (or diseases) would lead antivaxxers to reassess. However, this reaction of the antivaccine movement to COVID-19 should have been very predictable, just based on the experience from last year. As we saw then, with the return of measles in so many places due to low uptake of the MMR vaccine, the antivaccine movement was unmoved. In fact, it doubled down...
So, why should we be concerned about these folks and and their conspiratorial spewing of demonstrable falsehoods?
Well, as Gorski explains, one reason to be concerned is the fact that they have become very good at disseminating their 'messages' in a highly transmissible, essentially viral, manner on social media platforms. Additionally, they are one of the few groups anywhere that managed to forge bipartisan political alliances that are now beginning to tilt rightward:
...Despite the image of antivaxxers being hippy dippy, granola crunching lefties, in fact, antivaccine views are roughly equally prevalent on the political right and the left, and this has been true for a long time. However, over the last decade (and in particular since the passage of SB 277 in California to outlaw nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine mandates), increasingly the antivaccine movement has been appealing to the right more than the left through the use of conservative-friendly rhetoric of “freedom”, “parental rights”, and the portrayal of school vaccine mandates as overweening government overreach...
It's a very worrying situation, indeed.
And it would seem that the sooner it is dealt with effectively, the better.
______
Kevin Roose also wrote an excellent Op-Ed piece on this topic recently in the New York Times.
.
6 comments:
RossK, where you wrote 'Clinician-scientist David Gorski' I immediately discarded it .... because I 'saw' Christian-scientist David Gorski...oooops
Ha!
In my world it means that the guy not only messes around in the lab but is also a real doctor.
.
would probably still be able to achieve herd immunity
Bloomberg and Dr. Bonnie Henry
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-05-16/a-virus-epicenter-that-wasn-t-how-one-region-stemmed-the-deaths
paragraphs snip snip snippty
British Columbia’s success story shows how tried-and-true methods -- when paired with strong public health agencies -- can have sweeping impact, according to Kindrachuk and other scientists. Many governments embraced technology, with the U.K. using drones to help police enforce lockdowns and South Korea tapping location data from mobile carriers and credit-card transactions to track infections.
B.C. stuck to old-fashioned basics, alerting primary care doctors by fax about how to be on the lookout for the novel pathogen and tracing potential transmissions through interviews. Data compiled on May 13 show the province’s Covid-19 death rate was 3 per 100,000 residents, better than almost anywhere in North America and much of Europe.
Local officials would be the first to say that luck surely played a role. But British Columbia also had stockpiles of equipment along with the benefit of a public-health system making communication and coordination smoother than in U.S. states. And it had a provincial health officer, Dr. Bonnie Henry, with the power to order doctors and hospitals to take certain steps, such as canceling elective surgeries, which she did early on to free up beds.
Anon--
Are you sure about that?
_______
Thanks NVG--
We discussed that Bloomberg piece, here.
.
People don't trust their governments any more. I do wonder if N.Z. has a higher trust in vaccines. It has been reported they trust their government more than other countries.
Would I take a vaccine, if one were produced. If it comes out of Germany, Japan, Twaiwan, Canada, any number of countries I trust, you bet. If it came out of the U.S.A. I'm NOT so sure. I might wait a bit. Trump has "fucked" up everything in that country, removed scientists, etc. I not sure. I'd be ore inclined to take a vaccine for COVID out of China than the U.S.A. I just don't trust anything from there.
Part of it is "influencers" on goggle, facebook etc. People used to trust a lot of their media. Now not so much. Don't trust much which comes out of Postmedia. they were running ads which look like real news articles. Who do I trust? Dr. Tam, Dr. Henry, the other provincial Chief Medical Officers. My friends, not so much. Some spend too much time on Face Book. I trust some universities
I believe in vaccines. but then I was little kid before we had polio vaccines, remember getting tested for T.B. in high school with all the other kids, etc. makes a difference in your view point I think. I remember people dying of polio and I know people who had mild cases of it as children, and have one leg a tad shorter than the other, including one of the siblings, about a 1/4 of an inch.
Post a Comment